Journal of Neurology Research, ISSN 1923-2845 print, 1923-2853 online, Open Access |
Article copyright, the authors; Journal compilation copyright, J Neurol Res and Elmer Press Inc |
Journal website http://www.neurores.org |
Original Article
Volume 1, Number 2, June 2011, pages 59-68
Re-Justification for Reducing the Length of Hospital Stay Based on Community-Based Appraisal of Functional Recovery of Cerebrovascular Disease Patient
Tables
Deterioration | No change | Improvement | P | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
RIND: reversible ischemic neurological deficit; SAH: subarachnoid hemorrhage; BI: Barthel index; SD: standard deviation; LVH: low-volume hospital; IVH: intermediate-volume hospital; HVH: high-volume hospital; LOS: length of hospital stay; TC: total charge; SD: standard deviation. | ||||||
Overall | 668 | 11440 | 7067 | |||
Age | ||||||
Mean age [SD] | 73.7 [11.2] | 66.5 [13.2] | 69.5 [12.4] | < 0.001 | ||
65 - 74 years | 186 (27.8) | 3652 (31.9) | 2138 (30.3) | < 0.001 | ||
75 - 84 years | 246 (36.8) | 2618 (22.9) | 2065 (29.2) | |||
85 years and over | 108 (16.2) | 655 (5.7) | 644 (9.1) | |||
Gender | ||||||
Male | 370 (55.4) | 7561 (66.1) | 4256 (60.2) | < 0.001 | ||
Transfer | not at home | 329 (49.3) | 957 (8.4) | 1582 (22.4) | < 0.001 | |
Ambulance | Use | 184 (27.5) | 1918 (16.8) | 2658 (37.6) | < 0.001 | |
Principal disease | ||||||
Transient ischemia | 26 (3.9) | 1252 (10.9) | 563 (8) | < 0.001 | ||
Lacunar infarction | 129 (19.3) | 1613 (14.1) | 1237 (17.5) | |||
SAH | 13 (1.9) | 286 (2.5) | 269 (3.8) | |||
Hemorrhage | 47 (7) | 619 (5.4) | 706 (10) | |||
Nontraumatic subdural hematoma | 36 (5.4) | 580 (5.1) | 418 (5.9) | |||
Infarction | 370 (55.4) | 4801 (42) | 3542 (50.1) | |||
RIND | 47 (7) | 2289 (20) | 332 (4.7) | |||
BI at admission | ||||||
Dependent | 189 (28.3) | 982 (8.6) | 4174 (59.1) | < 0.001 | ||
Assisted independence | 108 (16.2) | 285 (2.5) | 1789 (25.3) | |||
Independence with minimal assistance | 371 (55.5) | 10173 (88.9) | 1104 (15.6) | |||
Charlson comorbidity index | < 0.001 | |||||
1 | 188 (28.1) | 3043 (26.6) | 1898 (26.9) | < 0.001 | ||
2 | 106 (15.9) | 1249 (10.9) | 1006 (14.2) | |||
3 | 40 (6) | 363 (3.2) | 349 (4.9) | |||
4 or more | 19 (2.8) | 134 (1.2) | 125 (1.8) | |||
Preexisting cognitive impairment | 2 (0.3) | 0 (0) | 5 (0.1) | < 0.001 | ||
Preexisting cerebrovascular disease | 111 (16.6) | 1835 (16) | 1041 (14.7) | 0.044 | ||
Atrial fibrillation or flutter | 52 (7.8) | 522 (4.6) | 477 (6.7) | < 0.001 | ||
Procedure-related complication | 8 (1.2) | 112 (1) | 60 (0.8) | 0.524 | ||
Cognitive impairment after admission | 3 (0.4) | 31 (0.3) | 22 (0.3) | 0.660 | ||
Deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism | 1 (0.1) | 20 (0.2) | 15 (0.2) | 0.827 | ||
Procedure | ||||||
Surgical procedure | ||||||
Present | 135 (20.2) | 1905 (16.7) | 864 (12.2) | < 0.001 | ||
Ventilation | ||||||
Administered | 10 (1.5) | 126 (1.1) | 60 (0.8) | 0.117 | ||
Mean days administered [SD] | 2.8 [3.6] | 3.9 [5.2] | 3.8 [7.3] | 0.847 | ||
Rehabilitation | ||||||
Administered | 398 (59.6) | 3392 (29.7) | 3769 (53.3) | < 0.001 | ||
Mean days administered [SD] | 16.0 [17.6] | 10.1 [12.9] | 12.9 [13.9] | < 0.001 | ||
Hospital | ||||||
Patient volume | ||||||
LVH | 212 (31.7) | 4233 (37.0) | 2087 (29.5) | < 0.001 | ||
IVH | 205 (30.7) | 3998 (34.9) | 2279 (32.2) | |||
HVH | 251 (37.6) | 3209 (28.1) | 2701 (38.2) | |||
Teaching status | ||||||
Academic | 141 (21.1) | 3247 (28.4) | 1196 (16.9) | < 0.001 | ||
Fiscal year | ||||||
2004 | 90 (3.8) | 1505 (63.4) | 779 (32.8) | < 0.001 | ||
2005 | 143 (3.5) | 2524 (60.9) | 1476 (35.6) | |||
2006 | 188 (3.2) | 3585 (60.5) | 2156 (36.4) | |||
2007 | 128 (3.7) | 1926 (55.4) | 1425 (41.0) | |||
2008 | 119 (3.7) | 1900 (58.5) | 1231 (37.9) | |||
Resource use | ||||||
Mean LOS, days [SD] | 27.6 [25.1] | 13.9 [14.2] | 19.4 [16.7] | < 0.001 | ||
Mean TC, $ [SD] | 10362 [8779] | 5948 [6199] | 7706 [6867] | < 0.001 |
Independent variables | Model 1 | Model 2 | Model 3 | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Estimation 95% CI | Estimation 95% CI | Estimation 95% CI | ||||
CI: confidence interval; RIND: reversible ischemic neurological deficit; SAH: subarachnoid hemorrhage; BI: Barthel index; LOS: length of stay; LVH: low-volume hospital; IVH: intermediate-volume hospital; HVH: high-volume hospital; a: LOS*15 - 64 years; b: LOS*65 - 74 years; c: LOS*75 - 84 years; d: LOS*85 – years; e: LOS*TIA; f: LOS*lacunar; g: LOS*SAH; h: LOS*hemorrhage; I: LOS*subdural hematoma; j: LOS*infarction; k: LOS*RIND. | ||||||
Intercept | 51.6 | [46.7 - 56.4] | 49.8 | [44.8 - 54.7] | 50.5 | [44.5 - 56.5] |
Age (for 15 - 64 years) | ||||||
65 - 74 years | -2.0 | [-3.2 - -0.8] | -0.4 | [-2.3 - 1.4] | -2.0 | [-3.2 - -0.8] |
75 - 84 years | -4.8 | [-6.0 - -3.5] | -2.1 | [-4.0 - -0.1] | -4.8 | [-6.0 - -3.5] |
85 years and over | -13.3 | [-15.2 - -11.4] | -10.6 | [-13.4 - -7.8] | -13.3 | [-15.1 - -11.4] |
Male | 0.4 | [-0.6 - 1.4] | 0.3 | [-0.7 - 1.3] | 0.3 | [-0.7 - 1.3] |
Transfer not at home | -16.2 | [-17.5 - -15.0] | -16.1 | [-17.4 - -14.9] | -16.2 | [-17.5 - -15.0] |
Ambulance | 4.0 | [2.9 - 5.1] | 4.0 | [2.9 - 5.1] | 4.0 | [2.8 - 5.1] |
Principal Diagnosis (for TIA) | ||||||
Lacunar | -1.0 | [-4.7 - 2.7] | -1.0 | [-4.8 - 2.7] | -0.6 | [-5.9 - 4.7] |
SAH | 16.6 | [11.6 - 21.6] | 16.4 | [11.3 - 21.4] | 20.8 | [13.3 - 28.4] |
Hemorrhage | 3.0 | [-0.9 - 6.9] | 2.9 | [-1 - 6.8] | 0.3 | [-5.3 - 6.0] |
Subdural hematoma | -2.2 | [-7.2 - 2.8] | -2.1 | [-7.1 - 3.0] | 3.8 | [-3.4 - 11.0] |
Infarction | -0.7 | [-4.3 - 2.9] | -0.7 | [-4.4 - 2.9] | 0.4 | [-4.7 - 5.5] |
RIND | 0.2 | [-4.0 - 4.4] | 0.2 | [-4.0 - 4.4] | 3.2 | [-3.1 - 9.5] |
BI at admission (for dependent) | ||||||
Assisted independence | -24.7 | [-26.2 - -23.2] | -24.7 | [-26.2 - -23.2] | -24.7 | [-26.2 - -23.2] |
Independence with minimal assistance | -46.3 | [-47.6 - -45.1] | -46.2 | [-47.4 - -45] | -46.3 | [-47.5 - -45.1] |
Charlson comorbidity index (for zero) | ||||||
1 | -1.0 | [-2.2 - 0.3] | -0.9 | [-2.1 - 0.3] | -1.0 | [-2.2 - 0.3] |
2 | -1.4 | [-2.8 - 0.0] | -1.4 | [-2.9 - 0.0] | -1.4 | [-2.9 - 0.0] |
3 | -1.3 | [-3.5 - 0.8] | -1.3 | [-3.4 - 0.9] | -1.4 | [-3.6 - 0.8] |
4 or more | -3.2 | [-6.6 - 0.1] | -3.1 | [-6.5 - 0.3] | -3.3 | [-6.6 - 0.1] |
Cerebral vascular accident | -0.2 | [-1.7 - 1.4] | -0.1 | [-1.6 - 1.4] | -0.1 | [-1.7 - 1.4] |
Dementia | -10.3 | [-26.8 - 6.3] | -10.3 | [-26.9 - 6.2] | -10.2 | [-26.7 - 6.4] |
Atrial fibrillation or flutter | -1.2 | [-3.1 - 0.6] | -1.2 | [-3.0 - 0.7] | -1.2 | [-3.1 - 0.7] |
Procedure-related complication | -2.7 | [-8.6 - 3.3] | -2.3 | [-8.3 - 3.6] | -3.0 | [-9.0 - 3.0] |
Cognitive impairment after admission | -1.3 | [-9.2 - 6.5] | -0.9 | [-8.7 - 7.0] | -1.0 | [-8.9 - 6.8] |
Deep vein thrombosis | -0.3 | [-9.4 - 8.8] | -0.2 | [-9.4 - 8.9] | -0.7 | [-9.8 - 8.4] |
Procedure (reference; Medical) | -1.8 | [-3.8 - 0.2] | -2.0 | [-4 - 0.0] | -2.2 | [-4.2 - -0.1] |
Ventilation | -4.0 | [-8.3 - 0.3] | -4.5 | [-8.8 - -0.2] | -3.6 | [-8.0 - 0.7] |
Patient volume (reference; LVH) | ||||||
IVH | -1.4 | [-3.7 - 0.9] | -1.4 | [-3.8 - 0.9] | -1.4 | [-3.7 - 0.9] |
HVH | 0.1 | [-2.6 - 2.9] | 0.1 | [-2.8 - 2.9] | 0.2 | [-2.7 - 3.0] |
Hospital (reference; Community) | ||||||
Academic | -1.2 | [-3.6 - 1.2] | -1.2 | [-3.7 - 1.2] | -1.2 | [-3.6 - 1.2] |
Fiscal year (for 2004) | ||||||
2005 | 1.5 | [-0.7 - 3.7] | 1.6 | [-0.7 - 3.8] | 1.5 | [-0.7 - 3.7] |
2006 | 1.6 | [-0.7 - 3.8] | 1.7 | [-0.5 - 4.0] | 1.7 | [-0.5 - 4.0] |
2007 | 2.4 | [0.1 - 4.7] | 2.5 | [0.2 - 4.9] | 2.6 | [0.2 - 4.9] |
2008 | 3.0 | [0.6 - 5.3] | 3.1 | [0.8 - 5.5] | 3.2 | [0.8 - 5.5] |
LOS, one more day | -0.174 | [-0.230 - -0.118] | a -0.104 | [-0.172 - -0.037] | e -0.114 | [-0.357 - 0.129] |
b -0.174 | [-0.243 - -0.106] | f -0.152 | [-0.230 - -0.074] | |||
c -0.224 | [-0.293 - -0.156] | g -0.250 | [-0.371 - -0.130] | |||
d -0.221 | [-0.306 - -0.136] | h -0.032 | [-0.124 - 0.061] | |||
i -0.417 | [-0.610 - -0.225] | |||||
j -0.181 | [-0.240 - -0.121] | |||||
k -0.252 | [-0.386 - -0.118] | |||||
Initiation of rehabilitation, one day delayed | 0.075 | [0.002 - 0.147] | 0.083 | [-0.001 - 0.167] | 0.079 | [-0.005 - 0.163] |
Rehabilitation, one more day | 0.075 | [-0.009 - 0.158] | 0.075 | [0.002 - 0.149] | 0.070 | [-0.003 - 0.143] |
Akaike information criteria | 67331.7 | 67207.0 | 67205.5 |
Independent variables | Odd ratio | 95% CI |
---|---|---|
CI: confidence interval; RIND: reversible ischemic neurological deficit; SAH: subarachnoid hemorrhage; BI: Barthel index; LOS: length of stay; LVH: low-volume hospital; IVH: intermediate-volume hospital; HVH: high-volume hospital. | ||
Age (for 15 – 64 years) | ||
65 – 74 years | 1.418 | [1.043 - 1.928] |
75 – 84 years | 1.886 | [1.394 - 2.552] |
85 years and over | 2.540 | [1.711 - 3.771] |
Male | 0.909 | [0.726 - 1.138] |
Transfer not at home | 6.402 | [4.993 - 8.207] |
Ambulance | 1.063 | [0.831 - 1.361] |
Principal Diagnosis (for TIA) | ||
Lacunar | 1.576 | [0.552 - 4.497] |
SAH | 0.813 | [0.220 - 2.999] |
Hemorrhage | 0.981 | [0.325 - 2.963] |
Subdural hematoma | 1.860 | [0.542 - 6.380] |
Infarction | 1.627 | [0.578 - 4.581] |
RIND | 1.071 | [0.336 - 3.417] |
BI at admission (for dependent) | ||
Assisted independence | 3.321 | [2.385 - 4.624] |
Independence with minimal assistance | 4.638 | [3.497 - 6.150] |
Charlson comorbidity index (for zero) | ||
1 | 1.003 | [0.759 - 1.325] |
2 | 1.083 | [0.793 - 1.481] |
3 | 1.228 | [0.782 - 1.930] |
4 or more | 1.896 | [1.034 - 3.476] |
Cerebral vascular accident | 1.238 | [0.896 - 1.712] |
Dementia | 4.624 | [0.242 - 88.343] |
Atrial fibrillation or flutter | 1.047 | [0.711 - 1.544] |
Procedure-related complication | 2.308 | [0.881 - 6.047] |
Cognitive impairment after admission | 1.355 | [0.265 - 6.933] |
Deep vein thrombosis | 0.329 | [0.033 - 3.250] |
Procedure (reference; Medical) | 1.294 | [0.878 - 1.907] |
Ventilation | 1.146 | [0.502 - 2.619] |
Patient volume (reference; LVH) | ||
IVH | 1.275 | [0.967 - 1.679] |
HVH | 1.357 | [1.036 - 1.777] |
Hospital (reference; Community) | ||
Academic | 0.849 | [0.632 - 1.141] |
Fiscal year (for 2004) | ||
2005 | 1.396 | [0.838 - 2.325] |
2006 | 1.101 | [0.660 - 1.838] |
2007 | 1.289 | [0.765 - 2.172] |
2008 | 1.168 | [0.690 - 1.979] |
LOS, one more day | 1.010 | [1.001 - 1.019] |
Initiation of rehabilitation, one day delayed | 1.016 | [1.002 - 1.031] |
Rehabilitation, one more day | 1.004 | [0.991 - 1.016] |
Cox & Snell R2, Nagelkerke R2 | 0.065, 0.191 |